Back

Designing a Performance Review Module

9 min read
9 min read

Designing a Performance Review Module

9 min read

Overview

Overview

Context

Litespace is a B2B SaaS platform that provides HRIS and EOR solutions to SMEs (Small and Medium-sized Enterprises). They also provide AI-driven solutions for HR tasks such as resumes screeners, candidate profilers, and AI interviews and assessments.

Task

Designing a Performance Reviews module, specifically for SMEs, by incorporating existing features in the platform.

Problem

Optimizing the overall review process, while maintaining functionality and addressing user needs.

Outcome

A tailored Performance Review module that cuts down the overall process duration by approximately 50%.

TEAM

ZS

MY RESPONSIBILITIES

Product Analysis

Secondary Research

Product Design

TIMELINE

Jul '24 to Aug '24

(3 months)

Review Writing Screen

First steps

Performance reviews is a fairly vast and complex process, and when I joined Litespace I had no knowledge about how the process works.

My first step involved understanding how performance reviews work from a high-level perspective and how they integrate with other process in an HRIS.

Simultaneously I also analyzed the competitors to understand the practical digital implementation of this complex workflow.

Competitors

High-level process: Performance reviews

Research file

Finding Clarity

After spending considerable time studying the performance review process, I prepared the feature architecture, by preparing a functional inventory which focused on pages and major tasks. The feature architecture and the functional inventory served as the foundations for the user flows, providing a clear picture of the digital process.

Functional inventory (Pages & Tasks): Performance reviews

Feature architecture: Performance reviews

User flow example: Editing a submitted response

User needs

I also did some desk research to understand what problems the target audience might face, mainly those who write reviews and those who receive them.

PAIN POINT 1

Reviews take loads of expensive staff hours and do not incorporate valuable historical context for fairness.

Read Article

PAIN POINT 2

Reviews fail to support employee growth, due to the absence of a clear feedback and goal alignment phase.

Solution

Along with delivering 15+ flows in 4 distinct modules that covered the entire performance reviews module, I designed 3 key solutions that directly addressed the pain points.

SOLUTION 1

AI Context for fair review writing assistance.

SOLUTION 2

Post-review feedback meetings.

SOLUTION 3

AI assisted questionnaire builder and review templates.

Design Process

Being in a fast-paced start-up, delivery needs to be quick and this module had to be done by the end of Q3. I followed a 3-phase, wireframe to mid-fidelity to high-fidelity approach in close connection with the co-founder which gave me enough time to gather feedback and improve designs over 2 iterations.

Design Process

AI Context

Litespace generates AI context through meeting data captured by a meeting agent. The context provides a summary from all meetings in the review cycle between an employee and their manager to ensure fairness through incorporation of data from real conversations, capturing the full picture.

I also integrated the existing shoutout module that highlights praises an employee gets from other employees at the workplace to capture positives from work.

How Shoutouts and AI context work together

Prototype: Viewing Praises and AI context

Solves pain point 1

AI Questions & Templates

Review cycle set up get's fairly exhausting sometimes, due to having to prepare a questionnaire that helps cover the review process. We provided pre-built templates for various use-cases, so teams could focus on what matters, which is writing the reviews. I also added a question generator, to help customize templates or build better questionnaires from scratch.

Mockup: Selecting a template

Solves pain point 1

Prototype: Preview and use template

Solves pain point 1

Post-review meetings

A review cycle is incomplete, if it doesn't positively help employees at the company. Post review meetings are advocated to make the most out of a review cycle, to address mismatch in employee and manager perspectives and reassess and realign goals for employees to help them grow.

Post-review meetings are automatically scheduled by the system if not within 5 business days of getting results, moreover the employee is prompted to schedule one when they view their results.

Prototype: Scheduling a post-review meeting

Solves pain point 2

Overall structure

Along with the above solutions, I designed flows for every sub-module within the scope of the project, which included:

Cycle Management

Templates

Review Writing

Prototype: Cycle settings

Prototype: Editing a template question

Prototype: Review writing & submission

Extra mockups: Analytics screens

Impact

Through deep secondary research, and Litespace's AI capabilities, I was able to improve and optimize the traditional implementation of performance reviews, significantly reducing the overall process duration and tailoring it for SME's.

IMPROVEMENTS

Quick AI Questions & Templates

AI Review Writing Assistance

Post-Review Feedback

PROCESS DURATION

approx.

50%

50%

50%

Next Steps

  1. Design and integrate the Goals & OKR module to complete the overall workflow.

  2. Provide actionable insights, potentially AI-assisted, based on collected review data to simplify calibration.

  3. Develop the combined Performance Reviews & Goals module.

Key Learnings

  1. Desk research and competitor product analysis are essential skills for understanding processes from the ground up and translating them into digital solutions.

  2. Real-world projects are far more complex than conceptual case studies.

  3. Journaling and thorough documentation help provide clarity when navigating complicated and dense projects.

Other Projects

Increasing Trust through
User Research

EXCELINK

Creating a Design System

EXCELINK

CONTENT

Umar Haque

Umar Haque

Umar Haque

Product Designer

Product Designer

Product Designer

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

09:02:15
09:02:15
09:02:15

Socials/Comms:

Socials/Comms:

Socials/Comms:

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.